Players were nominated for these awards by the Sports Information Directors at the various schools. All SIDs in the region were given the opportunity to vote.
First team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| G | Jim Conrad | Ohio Northern | Sr. | Cridersville, Ohio |
| G | Rodney Mitchell | Wooster | Sr. | Elida, Ohio |
| F | Thad Davis | Baldwin-Wallace | Jr. | Elyria, Ohio |
| C | Travis Schwab | Ohio Wesleyan | Sr. | Medina, Ohio |
| C | Lucas Messer | Heidelberg | Jr. | Clyde, Ohio |
Second team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| G | Matt Magnusen | Allegheny | Sr. | Plum, Pa. |
| G | Tony Borghese | Otterbein | Jr. | Columbus, Ohio |
| F | Mike Drahos |
Bethany |
So. | Wheeling, W. Va. |
| F | Andy Phillips | Hope | So. | White Pigeon, Mich. |
| C | David Gibbons |
John Carroll | Sr. | Charleston, W.Va. |
Third team
| Pos. | Name | School | Yr. | Hometown |
| G | Brian Schaefer | Adrian | Jr. | Strongsville, Ohio |
| G | Mark DeMonaco | Westminster (Pa.) | So. | New Castle, Pa. |
| F | Dan Aultman | Calvin | Jr. | Ludington, Mich. |
| F | Tanner Prosser | Grove City | Sr. | Pittsburgh, Pa. |
| F | Peter Walker | Wittenberg | Sr. | Louisville, Ky. |